Stephen Warren
Subject: Early National History, Native American History
Summary and Keywords
Described as a “chief among chiefs” by the British, and by his
arch-rival, William Henry Harrison, as “one of those uncommon geniuses
which spring up occasionally to produce revolutions and overturn the
established order of things,” Tecumseh impressed all who knew him.
Lauded for his oratory, military and diplomatic skills, and, ultimately,
his humanity, Tecumseh presided over the greatest Indian resistance
movement that had ever been assembled in the eastern half of North
America. His genius lay in his ability to fully articulate religious,
racial, and cultural ideals borne out of his people’s existence on fault
lines between competing empires and Indian confederacies. Known as
“southerners” by their Algonquian relatives, the Shawnees had a history
of migrating between worlds. Tecumseh, and his brother, Tenskwatawa,
converted this inheritance into a widespread social movement in the
first decade and a half of the 19th-century, when more than a thousand
warriors, from many different tribes, heeded their call to halt American
expansion along the border of what is now Ohio and Indiana. Tecumseh
articulated a vision of intertribal, pan-Indian unity based on
revitalization and reform, and his ambitions very nearly rewrote early
American history.
Primary Sources
For
an excellent, chronologically arranged collection of sources related to
both Tecumseh and the Shawnees, historians should first consult the
Shawnee Papers, housed in the Erminie Wheeler-Voegelin Archives at
Indiana University’s Glenn Black Laboratory of Archaeology. This
collection contains a wealth of primary sources, gathered together by an
exceptional team of anthropologists and historians through their work
on behalf of the Indian Claims Commission. As such, this collection
offers a useful springboard into more difficult and harder-to-reach
archival sources.
Tecumseh’s own words come to us through Anthony
Shane and Stephen Ruddell, white captives of the Shawnees who were
raised alongside Tecumseh. The oral historian and archivist Lyman Draper
interviewed both men about Tecumseh in the 1840s, years after his
death. Draper also interviewed and corresponded with a host of
Tecumseh’s adversaries, and their recollections can be found in the
Tecumseh Papers of the Lyman Copeland Draper Collection, which have been
microfilmed by the State Historical Society of Wisconsin.
Colonizers
left behind a rich, but terribly biased, source record on Tecumseh. For
example, many of Tecumseh’s speeches can be found in the papers of his
foremost adversary, William Henry Harrison, published by the Indiana
Historical Society. Similarly, the papers of Thomas Forsyth and Simon
Kenton offer useful, but adversarial, perspectives on pan-Indianism.
Historians should also consult British perspectives on Tecumseh,
including the papers of John Askin, William Claus, and the McKee family.
In the 19th century, neither British nor American historians bothered
to interview Shawnees about Tecumseh and his legacy. A century later,
the ethnohistorian Erminie Wheeler-Voegelin interviewed Shawnees about
Tecumseh, and her papers are housed at the Newberry Library.
Read the complete version at:
http://americanhistory.oxfordre.com/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780199329175.001.0001/acrefore-9780199329175-e-309
Visit the Official Web Site of the Piqua Shawnee at piquashawnee.com